Select Page

Several Improved Designs of Descaling Pumps

Aug 30, 2024 | Industry Outlook | 0 comments

The descaling pump is a key equipment in the descaling system of a steel plant. Whether the descaling pump can operate safely and for a long time has become a key factor affecting the surface quality of steel and steel production. This article analyzes the problems that occurred in the operation of the descaling pump of Anshan Iron and Steel Co., Ltd., mainly from the aspects of the bearing body and bracket parts, cylinder parts, and pump shaft, and puts forward several suggestions for improving the design.

Descaling pump, vibration, strength, broken shaft

Anshan Iron and Steel descaling pump is a domestic high-pressure multi-stage double-shell centrifugal pump. The main problems of this pump are excessive vibration, sudden performance decline, broken shaft, etc. The hydraulic design of the pump and the careful installation, operation and maintenance of the pump and possible safety rules on site are not within the scope of this article. Based on the problems that occurred on site, this article only discusses and analyzes the structural design of the pump and puts forward several suggestions for improving the design.

The flow rate of the descaling pump is about 300m³/h~400m³/h, the head is about 2500m, and the descaling is intermittent (variable frequency). Because the pump has high head, frequent changes in speed, and the medium contains solid particles and other harsh operating conditions, and because the descaling pump is a key equipment in the steel plant descaling system, the design of the pump should give priority to overcoming harsh operating conditions and ensuring the safe and stable operation of the pump.

Original pump structure

The original descaling pump used for medium and thick plates of Anshan Iron and Steel is a product of a well-known domestic water pump factory. As shown in the figure below, the pump is mainly composed of rotor components, suction vortex chamber, barrel components, middle section, guide vanes, balancing mechanism, rear pump cover, bracket, and shaft seal.

The rotor components are radially supported and axially fixed with two radial bearing components and thrust bearing components. The fan-shaped block of the thrust bearing component bears the residual axial force that is not completely balanced by the balancing mechanism of the pump. The suction port of the impeller is facing the suction end of the pump and is slid onto the shaft step by step. A compressible winding gasket group is installed between the last guide vane and the rear pump cover, so that the rear pump cover can reliably press the “pump core” into the pump barrel component. The shaft seals at both ends of the pump are sealed with packing.

Vibration

The vibration value of the bearing body of the pump was about 4.2 mm/s when it was shipped out of the factory. With the increase in the number of uses and repairs, the vibration value of the bearing body became larger and larger, reaching as high as 7.5 mm/s. Excessive vibration will increase the abrasion of the wear ring and the rotor, reduce the efficiency of the pump, and in severe cases cause downtime, which is costly. Careful processing, strict inspection and careful installation can effectively reduce vibration. However, vibration caused by design is not easy to be discovered and solved.

The vibration fault spectrum of the pump is characterized by 2 times the frequency (2X). There are many reasons for the 2 times the frequency. Excluding the reasons such as rotor misalignment, friction and loose components, the most likely cause of vibration is the bearing [1]. Analyzing the original pump structure, the bracket component and the bearing body component are the weak points of the pump. The bearing body and the bracket component of the pump that fixes the bearing body are designed in the form of lower semicircular support. This design reduces the stiffness of the bracket and the stability of the bearing body, and there is a hidden danger of causing vibration.

Therefore, when improving the design, it is necessary to focus on strengthening the stiffness of the bearing body and the bracket component. The bearing body and the bracket component are changed to a full circle design. The number and size of the openings in the bracket components should be reduced as much as possible. The openings in the bracket components only need to meet the function of completing the machine locking and pipe connection functions, and the rigidity of the bracket components should be increased to the maximum extent. The improved bracket component (sealing box body) is shown in the figure below.

Under the same boundary conditions, simulation analysis shows that the maximum stress of the bracket after the design improvement is 0.63 times that of the original pump, and the maximum displacement of the bracket after the design improvement is only 0.18 times that of the original pump. As shown in the figure below;

Abnormal performance degradation

The descaling pump was operated at Anshan Iron and Steel for a period of time, and the pressure suddenly dropped. It could no longer meet the descaling requirements of medium and thick plates, and was forced to stop the pump for maintenance. After disassembling and inspecting the pump, it was found that there were no obvious defects in the impeller and guide vane flow channel, and the guide vane and middle section sealing surface were intact. The gap between the stator sealing ring and the rotor sealing ring was within the design range. However, when inspecting the barrel parts, it was found that there was a through hole between the suction port of the pump and the outer diameter of the suction vortex chamber (R1 in the figure below), and a “backflow” phenomenon occurred.

After analysis, it was found that the pressure difference was the largest at this location, and sufficient strength was required. However, the original pump design did not receive enough attention, and no corresponding measures were taken, resulting in the breakdown of this location and the appearance of a through hole. Due to the difficulty in on-site pipeline construction at Anshan Iron and Steel, it was not possible to increase the thickness of this location by offsetting the suction port. Therefore, some design improvements could only be made without changing the on-site installation dimensions.

By analyzing the original design of the pump barrel components, design improvements can be made from the following aspects:

(1) Increase the thickness of the cylinder component at the pressure differential position. While meeting the installation requirements, reduce the thickness of the suction vortex chamber flange and change the axial dimensions of the first-stage middle section and the first-stage guide vane. Increase the thickness of the cylinder component at the pressure differential position from the original 28mm to 43mm, so as to enhance the strength of the cylinder component at the pressure differential position.

(2) Change the stress concentration point of the cylinder component. The arc R1 of the cylinder component at the pressure differential position is not enough to meet the need to reduce stress concentration. Increasing the arc (radial and toward the outlet) does not affect the strength of the cylinder component at all, as shown in the figure below. This improvement was found to effectively reduce the stress singularity point [2] through finite element analysis and enhance the pressure resistance at the stress concentration point.

(3) Add an inlet reinforcing rib plate. In order to reduce the deformation of the cylinder parts that are subjected to pressure difference and not affect the flow rate, a 20mm thick inlet reinforcing rib plate is welded at the suction port (low-pressure side) of the cylinder parts. The welding groove should be processed before welding the reinforcing rib plate. After welding, the weld is required to be strictly inspected to ensure that the reinforcing rib plate is firm while reducing the deformation of the weak points of the cylinder parts.

Broken shaft

The original pump shaft fracture mainly concentrated on the first-stage impeller shoulder. The original pump shaft impeller shaft diameter was 110mm, the span between the two bearing support points was 2573mm, and the length-to-diameter ratio was about 23.39. This value is greater than the empirical value of 20 [3], proving that the rotor stiffness of the pump is insufficient. As shown in Figure 1, the original pump impeller adopts a “candied haws” structure design, and the rear-stage impeller is positioned by the front-stage impeller. In this way, the axial force generated by all impellers acts on the first-stage impeller shoulder. Therefore, the original pump had a pump shaft fracture phenomenon at the first-stage impeller shoulder.

After analysis, the improved design is carried out from the following aspects:

(1) When the hydraulic size allows and meets the requirements of on-site installation, the shaft diameter at the impeller is increased to ¢125mm, the span between the bearing support points is shortened to 2450mm, and the length-to-diameter ratio is about 19.6, slightly less than the empirical value of 20.

(2) Change the impeller fixing method to “separate positioning at each stage”, and each impeller is independently fixed on the shaft through the interstage retaining ring to reduce the force on the first-stage impeller shoulder. However, it should be noted that alloy steel is highly sensitive to stress concentration, and stress concentration and fatigue failure are very likely to occur at the interstage retaining ring groove and the half retaining ring groove. If the arc at this position is small, it will form a very high local stress concentration, and there is a risk of pump shaft fracture. The fillet at this position should be increased as much as possible.

(3) Choose a pump shaft material with higher strength. 17-4PH (ZG0Cr17Ni4CuNb) is a typical martensitic precipitation hardening stainless steel. The material has a low nickel content and a martensitic transformation temperature higher than room temperature. After the martensitic transformation, it is aged at 480-620℃ to further enhance its strength. It has good high-temperature mechanical properties below 400℃. All mechanical performance indicators are better than 3Cr13, and it is more suitable for use as a pump shaft for transmitting large torque on descaling pumps.

(4) Change the layout of the impeller keyway. Practice has shown that the 180° symmetrical arrangement of the keyways of two adjacent impellers can easily cause stress concentration at the keyways. Changing the keyways of two adjacent impellers to a 120° arrangement can make the pump shaft more evenly stressed.

As an important equipment of the descaling system, the descaling pump is the most critical factor affecting the output and quality of steel. The working conditions of the pump’s frequent speed increase and decrease require that the design of the descaling pump must have a higher safety factor than other large high-pressure pumps. This article only puts forward a few suggestions for improving the design of the problematic parts on site at Anshan Iron and Steel. The design verification of other parts of the pump is also indispensable. With the development of science and technology, CFD should also become a reliable means of design verification and confirmation, minimizing the possibility of on-site failures from a design perspective.

The manufacture, installation and maintenance of the descaling pump are equally important. Only by ensuring that all links are well done can the descaling pump be guaranteed to operate long-term, stably and safely, providing a strong guarantee for the output and quality of medium and thick steel plates in steel plants.

WhatsApp Online logo

Online Service


Sales Director-Mr.Jasper Lee

Sales Manager-Mrs.Wendy Fu

Spare Parts Sales-Miss. Nora Cao

After-Sales Manager-Miss. Tina Zhang

Merchandiser-Miss. Yoyo Tao

Contact EMAC Now!

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Subscribe to get the latest updates from www.ebara-pumps.com

Welcome on board, we will keep you updated with latest news and business activities!

Pin It on Pinterest